News

Bookmark and Share

My Stats

  • Posts - 309
  • Comments - 259
  • Trackbacks - 82

Twitter












Tag Cloud


Recent Comments


Recent Posts


Article Categories


Archives


Post Categories


Entertainment


Friends


Tech/Geek



In Part I of this series I explained how my apartment was burglarized and how my first attempt to secure the place fell short for me in a few areas. I stated three goals that I had for the future:

  • I want to setup and maintain a solid backup system for all of my data.
  • I want to physically secure my Windows Home Server.
  • I want to integrate my alarm and video surveillance systems.

In this post I’ll show you what I’m doing to fulfill the first of my goals, creating a backup strategy for all of my data. Sounds boring and well it probably is but honestly this took a lot of thought, research and work. I hope I’m covered – if anyone sees any holes in my process or has any suggestions please leave a comment!

I was REALLY lucky that the thieves didn’t take my Windows Home Serve (WHS) because I didn’t have a backup strategy. Yes I KNOW! I would have lost all of my digital pictures and home videos. I shudder to think about it. Makes me almost sick to my stomach. The losers DID take my laptop but I already use Windows Live Mesh to sync my documents between my computers (laptop, home desktop and work desktop) so I didn’t really lose anything on the laptop.

I have even more reason now to make sure my WHS is backed up offsite and in (close to) real-time. My video surveillance software, Blue Iris, records directly to my WHS. I was having a very hard time keeping everything straight in my head so I started of with a simple diagram:

 

Lets see if I can explain what I’m doing without writing a novel then go into more detail about each piece below: My documents are synchronized between my three main machines and my Live Desktop via Live Mesh. My home computers al all backed up (complete images) to my WHS. My work computer is backed up nightly to a WHS at work. My media (photos, home videos, music) are backed up to KeepVault Online from my WHS. My media and computer backups are also backed up to a rotating backup disk that I move to work once per month.

A little more detail about each piece of the puzzle:

Live Mesh
Awesome service. Keeps my documents synchronized in near real-time between my laptop, home desktop and work machines. I love being able to save a doc at work then come home and open it and work on it. No emailing work back and forth. It just works. If I have one complaint is that on occasion the “Mesh Operating Environment” or MOE process takes up quite a bit of processor cycles. This seems to become less of a problem lately – so maybe Microsoft has been working on the issue? Be warned that Mesh is NOT a backup solution. If you delete a file from one machine… POOF it vanishes from all of the machines that are syncing to that file AND it’s gone from your Live Desktop. Mesh is part of my backup strategy but only in that it syncs my documents on all my machines and allows the other pieces of the strategy to work effectively. In case I do accidentally delete a file and Live Mesh does it’s duty and kiss it everywhere I have several options to recover that file such as ShadowCopy and my mightly WHS backups. Mostly though Live Mesh provides an immediate fail safe in case one machine (or hard drive) dies, gets stolen or burns up in a fire.

 

WHS Computer Backup
My Windows Home Server backs up all of my home machines every night. WHS computer backups have saved many people’s asses… including mine when a hard drives in both my home desktop machine and my laptop died. Recovery was simple and painless. In addition the WHS backups allow EASY upgrades to new hard drives. Remove old drive, insert new drive, recover the backup to new drive. (No the drives do not need to be the same size.) Done! To augment the WHS backups I use a WHS add-in called  WHS Backup Database Backup (BDBB) to backup my computer backups to an external hard drive (which is rotated offsite monthly).

 

Keep Vault
As of this writing KeepVault seems to be the only online backup service that officially supports Windows Home Server. I signed up for 100GB of online storage for $99 per year. Cheap really - $8.25 per month - skipping a couple lattes would cover the cost and the peace of mind it gives me is WELL worth it. I use the KeepVault WHS Add-In to backup my media (pictures, music, home videos) and surveillance videos directly from my home server. I also use KeepVault to backup my media to an external hard drive (which is rotated offsite monthly). Keepvault encrypts and compresses all information that is backed up to the cloud and to the external drive.

 

External Hard Drive

I have an external  SATA –> USB hard drive dock (a Thermaltake BlacX Duet) connected to my Windows Home Server. I drop an extra hard drive in one of the slots and let KeepVault take over. The KeepVault WHS add-in has a tab for local backups… so I point it at this removable drive and let it do the work of backing up all of my media and WHS BDBB backups to the external drive. I have an reoccurring Google calendar item to remind me to swap out the hard drive once per month. Right now I move them to my work office (which is about 20 miles from home). I am considering a safe deposit box for more secure storage.

 

So there you have it my personal backup strategy! I’d love to hear any comments of criticisms!


posted @ Wednesday, October 07, 2009 6:52 AM | Filed Under [ Geek Toys & Gadgets Windows Home Serer ]

Comments

Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Aaron on 10/7/2009 1:24 PM
I'm enjoying this series on home security and backup! I'm also a WHS owner and I've also been thinking about home security a lot lately. In fact, recently I bought a D-Link DCS-910 and hooked it up for home surveillance.

I chose zoneminder for my video surveillance software. It's Linux-based, so I run it in a VM on one of my PC's. It's pretty cool:
http://www.zoneminder.com/

Also, on the topic of WHS backup, being a cheapskate I've been using a free app called CrashPlan. One great feature it offers is computer-to-computer backup over the net. I've got plenty of storage space on my computer at work, so I've configured CrashPlan on both my home WHS as well as my work PC, and each night WHS does an incremental backup from home to work. I think the pay version of CrashPlan does it in realtime.
http://www4.crashplan.com/consumer/features-specs.html

How are you liking the GE Simon system that you described in part 1?

Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Paul Roberts on 10/9/2009 11:30 PM
Steve,

I like your strategy overall! For my needs, there are too many layers to manage. I need less to think and do. That has caveats too, but I don't want to spend too much time with backups.

I too have WHS as centralized storage with duplication turned on. I run HandyBackup on WHS and it FTP's my very important data (irreplaceable pictures and docs, but not everything) to a hosted server. All encrypted and zipped up. It does this off site backup each week. Next, everything (Media and music, along with the "important data" above) gets backed up to a 1.5tb network drive stashed in the basement.

This suits my needs and the way I work. Each has his/her own.
Thanks for the share!
Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Tom Halter on 10/10/2009 12:53 AM
Very similar to my strategy. I use live mesh to backup/synchronize my documents, CrashPlan for my online backup (the paid plan with online storage).

I prefer crash plan because it is a little cheaper (As I recall, it was less than $70 per year for unlimited storage). CrashPlan also lets me throttle my upstream bandwidth usage so that it can run continuously.

As to Paul's comments, backups are just like firewalls and anti-virus - you need a layered defense. If you have just a single backup layer and you lose that layer, then you've got nothing. It is not difficult to add one additional layer to WHS (such as an online backup like KeepVault, CrashPlan, or Mozy).
Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Paul Roberts on 10/10/2009 7:42 AM
Oh, I understand completely the use of AV and back ups. But, I do have a multi layer backup. I use HAndy Backup on WHS running as a service. It FTP's my items to my host server weekly.

I just don't like the added work of a Cloud, Extra USB drives and rotating them etc. Per above, WHS is backed up and dup'd, FTP the important stuff weekly and USB drive backup too. That is three copies of data in two different places. Same thing just a little different ;-)
Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Walt Hamilton on 10/11/2009 12:05 AM
My backup plan is not as elaborate as everyone else describes but it works for me. I have an internal HD that backs up weekly and a monthly external USB HD that is used to transport my important data (Girl's Fastpitch Softball photos)to my other WHS computer on a local network (no internet access) located about 250 miles away where I have 2 TB HD's of backups of both WHS's in a fireproof safe.
Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Pascal Walschots on 10/12/2009 7:45 AM
Looking at my storage requirements (about 1T) the 'cloud' back up solution using KeepVault or even Amazon would be 100's of $. I'm considering a model where I put a second WHS into my Dad's house, as he has a fast connection as well. I'm just trying to understand if there are any available software solutions to automate the sync between 2 WHS?
Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Steve Bargelt on 10/12/2009 12:28 PM
@Aaron - I looked at Crash Plan but wanted something with "official" WHS support and a WHS Add-In. Need it? No. Wanted it? Yes. I love my GE Simon XT... so simple and inexpensive but still quality. More on that soon!

@Pascal 1TB to backup? WOW! I vertainly USE more than I can feasibly backup tot he cloud but I don't backup my ripped DVDs and Blu-Ray(YES I own all of them!) since I figure the plastic media is the "backup." I think with CrashPlan you can "seed" the backup drive so you wouldn't initially have to send the 1TB over the Internet to your Dad's house. Might be a great option for you.


Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Pascal Walschots on 10/15/2009 12:24 AM
@Steve
I'm looking at storage of my HD video files and RAW photoimages, which adds up pretty quickly ;-)
As I'm in Europe Crashplan looks not to be available as a solution. I've found some people who use SyncToy to keep 2 WHS servers in sync.
Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by JB on 11/30/2009 5:06 PM
Any secret to getting the Blackx duet working on your WHS? Having trouble getting mine to recognize.
Gravatar # re: Feeling Secure Part II -- Backup Strategy
Posted by Steve Bargelt on 12/1/2009 3:57 AM
@JB No secret to getting the Duet to work for me - just plugged it in, added a drive and it worked. Although you may need to go into drive manager to format the drive etc.
Gravatar # another strategy
Posted by rupert on 2/6/2010 1:32 AM
Some good ideas and strategys here :)
I use a dns323 nas to backup all my stuff, well 2 actually. 1 is my main local (and ssh remote) storage. The second is a nightly rotating backup using rsync over ssh and hardlinking, like apples time machine.
Cheap hands off solution that works for me. I'd like to move my backup offsite but havent got round to it yet tho :)

Post A Comment
Title:
Name:
Email:
Website:
Comment:
Verification: